After tracking down Doctor Williams, Smith and Hoke learn more about the Floating Man whose name is Peter. Meanwhile, back at the Land of Never the kids are becoming disillusioned with Peter and his actions. Instead, they prefer their big sister Wendy and are very vocal about this. This obviously creates a problem with the ever more unstable Peter.

Sometimes families don’t see eye to eye, and sometimes that leads to death. As Peter continues to build his Neverland family, there is uncertainty and apprehension from some. Wendy is put in a position to keep the family together. Meanwhile, Hoke and Smith are getting closer to putting together who the Floating Man actually is.

And we’re off to Never-Neverland and we aren’t talking about Metallica. Wendy finds herself in a cage as the “Floating Man” keeps saying weird things that she doesn’t understand. She discovers she’s not alone as she now has a “little brother” in Rufus. But as she deals with her and Rufus’ nightmare, her dad and Rufus’ dad are not giving up the search for them even if the police have.

A father’s worst nightmares come true as his daughter is abducted from their home by a big induvial wearing a baby mask. The worst part is nobody believes him and this makes him a suspect to boot. What lengths will go through to find his daughter and the person who kidnapped her?