BABYLON COVE #5 (Mad Cave Studios)
Heather must finally come face to face with Karthon. To overcome his grasp and save Babylon Cove she must face her past mistakes and show that she has truly changed. Will Teratia help her out once again or will she choose to become the evil queen Karthon wants her to be?
Babylon Cove #5 - Written By Rafer Roberts – Drawn By Joe Eisma - Colors By Marissa Louise – Letters By Crank! - Edited By Ryan Carroll & James B. Emmett - Published By Mad Cave Studios
Credit: Mad Cave Studios
*** POSSIBLE SPOILER WARNING ***
WRITING:
This final issue does a strong job of tying up the series’ major loose ends and bringing Heather’s journey to a conclusion that feels logical and emotionally earned. Rafer Roberts keeps the focus on Heather’s final stage of growth, showing how far she has come since the beginning of the story. When the series started, she was self-centered, conceited, and often unwilling to consider how her actions affected the people around her. Over the course of the series, however, she has gradually learned to take responsibility, listen to others, and recognize that saving Babylon Cove requires more than simply proving herself. In this issue, those lessons finally come together as she is forced to confront the consequences of her past choices and decide what kind of person she wants to be moving forward. Her transformation into someone who genuinely considers other people’s feelings and is willing to put the town’s safety ahead of her own interests has been the emotional highlight of the series. More than the monsters, magic, or larger conflict, Heather’s personal evolution has been the true purpose of the story, and this finale gives that arc a satisfying sense of completion.
The horror element of the story has always remained on the lighter side, and that approach continues in this issue. There are monsters, supernatural threats, and moments of danger, but the book never becomes so graphic or oppressive that it loses its sense of fun. That restraint makes the series accessible even to readers who may be squeamish or who do not normally gravitate toward full-scale horror. Instead of relying entirely on gore or shock value, Roberts uses the horror to create urgency while allowing the characters’ personalities and relationships to remain at the center of the narrative. The humor takes an even more prominent role in this final issue and provides an effective counterbalance to the tension. Throughout the run, the cast’s banter, sarcastic exchanges, and tongue-in-cheek jokes have helped define the series’ voice, but here those elements are pushed right to the forefront. The comedy keeps the finale energetic and prevents its heavier emotional moments from becoming overly bleak. Most importantly, the humor feels connected to the characters rather than inserted simply to break the tension, making the issue’s blend of horror, heart, and comedy feel consistent with everything the series has established.
The only element that did not fully click for me in this final issue was the predictability of the ending. Roberts had created an ambitious setup with enough strange characters, supernatural possibilities, and complicated relationships to deliver one last unexpected turn, but the story ultimately follows the safest and most familiar path. The major confrontations resolve largely as expected, and the characters end up in places that feel appropriate without ever being especially surprising. A well-placed curveball could have made Heather’s final decision feel even more challenging or forced the reader to reconsider something the series had established earlier. Instead, the conclusion confirms what the story had already been building toward. Even the epilogue feels as though it is playing things safe and following a familiar formula, offering closure without adding one final memorable complication or revelation. None of this ruins the issue or weakens the series as a whole, because the character arcs still reach meaningful conclusions and the central themes remain intact. Still, after such an imaginative and ambitious run, I would have liked the finale to take a bigger creative swing and deliver an ending with more surprise, impact, or emotional risk. As written, the conclusion is satisfying and competent, but it also feels more routine than the rest of the series deserved.
ARTWORK:
The artwork in this final issue preserves the fun, vibrant energy that has defined the series from the beginning, while still giving the finale enough visual weight to make its emotional moments land. Joe Eisma brings Babylon Cove and its strange inhabitants to life with expressive character work, clean storytelling, and a lively sense of movement. His more cartoon-inspired style keeps the book playful and approachable, even when the characters are surrounded by monsters, supernatural danger, or moments that could easily have been presented as far more disturbing. At the same time, the exaggerated style never prevents the cast from feeling sincere. Small shifts in posture, wide-eyed reactions, and carefully drawn facial expressions communicate fear, frustration, determination, and affection without slowing the pace for additional explanation. That balance is especially important in an issue that moves between comedy, action, and heartfelt character beats. Eisma can make a creature look threatening in one panel and amusing in the next, allowing the horror and humor to coexist naturally. His ability to depict situations that should be frightening while still finding the comedy within them is a testament to both his character work and his strong understanding of the series’ tone.
What makes the artwork stand out even more is Marissa Louise’s color work. Her vibrant palette reinforces the playful personality of the series and gives every page an immediate sense of energy. A story filled with monsters, magic, death, and occasional gore could easily have leaned on heavy shadows, muted colors, and a generally grim appearance. Instead, Louise moves in the opposite direction, using bright, bold hues to create a visual identity that feels distinctive and perfectly matched to the book’s irreverent tone. The colors help separate characters and important details during the busier action sequences, keeping the storytelling clear even when a great deal is happening in a panel. They also support the emotional shifts in the issue, allowing warmer or more intense tones to strengthen a scene without overwhelming Eisma’s linework. Most importantly, the palette prevents the darker subject matter from making the book feel oppressive. Even during moments of violence or danger, the pages retain their sense of fun and visual momentum. That choice softens the harsher edges of the horror and makes the series more inviting to readers who enjoy supernatural stories but may not be interested in relentlessly bleak or graphic material.
Crank!’s lettering is clean, easy to follow, and consistently supports the rhythm of the story. The placement of the dialogue keeps conversations moving smoothly across each page, guiding the reader from panel to panel without obscuring the artwork or making the more crowded scenes feel confusing. The lettering also contributes to the emotional clarity of the issue. Variations in emphasis and presentation help distinguish quieter exchanges from moments of panic, comedy, or confrontation, allowing the reader to understand how a line should sound without the effect becoming overly showy. The visual differences between the narration boxes and the dialogue balloons create an immediate separation between internal commentary and spoken conversation, which helps the story maintain its brisk pace. My favorite aspect of Crank!’s work, however, is the treatment of the sound effects and action words. Their size, shape, and placement give impacts, sudden movements, and supernatural events an extra burst of personality. They feel integrated into the artwork rather than simply layered on top of it, adding energy and humor to the action while remaining readable. It is clear that Crank! had fun designing these moments, and that enthusiasm elevates the sequences without allowing the lettering to become distracting or compete with the rest of the page.
CHECK OUT MY REVIEW OF BABYLON COVE #4
Final Thoughts:
Babylon Cove #5 delivers a satisfying conclusion centered on Heather’s growth, supported by sharp humor, expressive artwork, vibrant colors, and energetic lettering. Although the finale follows a predictable path and could have taken a bigger creative risk, it brings the series’ central themes and character arcs to a rewarding close. If you have been following this series issue to issue you should be satisfied with this finale. For anyone that is looking for a fun and campy horror series, grab a copy of the Trade when it drops in December.
FINAL GRADE: 8/10
Let me know your thoughts on Babylon Cove #5 in the comments below. Thanks for reading!
